I stopped by for dinner on a Friday evening. Luckily I got the last seat. Duo of silk pie was my favorite item here. It had a nice peanut butter layer and a chocolate layer. I also went for a cherry pie milkshake. I think cherry pie and milkshake makes a wierd combination. I should have gone for some other pie, or may be a regular milk shake. Grilled Salmon platter was my favorite entree. Friday fish fry was good as well. It came with a soft bread which I throughly enjoyed.

This diner can be unpredictable. Arrive before the locals for fantastic breakfast and attentive service. Their pies are amazing--perfect for Pi Day, but order ahead! The decor is old-fashioned, ideal for fans of the classic 1950s-1960s vibe.

Great brunch place. This is our go-to place for a good, down-home meal in a friendly, 'cozy', environment. Our server was so very friendly, despite the pace being packed (being the weekend after Thanksgiving.) Despite being packed, our wait was only about 10-15min. It's worth the wait. Whenever friends visit, they insist on heading to Hubbard Ave for brunch....they didn't have to ask twice. We love tusk little diner!

This is a nice, clean location to meet up for a little breakfast or lunch. The menu has a nice variety of items so you can be sure everyone will be able to have something they like. The old-timey decor is a cool throwback that I really enjoyed. The food is good. Since we were there for breakfast, I dove head-first into the carnivore ("meat lovers") omelette. More of a concern than a complement - there was actually too much meat! I didn't expect that... it was fine, but the meat was overpowering and it no longer felt like an egg dish. Next time, I'll dial it back with a more basic omelette (or just fried eggs or something). Staff were very friendly and took great care of my mom (her 80th) birthday. The inside is clean and spacious, so it never got too loud or crazy. Very nice.

I absolutely adore diners in Madison, and my recent visit to here was simply delightful. I opted for the Mile High omelet, packed with ham, green peppers, onions, and cheddar cheese, served alongside hash browns, a fluffy biscuit, and a side of avocado. Every bite was a burst of flavor! As someone who's quite particular about biscuits (thanks to my grandma's homemade morning treats), I was thrilled that @hubbardavenuediner's biscuit lived up to my high expectations. While I prefer my hash browns crispy, they were still delicious. Needless to say, I'll be returning for more!

We traveled from Cincinnati to meet friends from Minneapolis in Middleton, WI. We asked the receptionist at the hotel about local restaurants, and he recommended the Hubbard Avenue Diner. We went there for dinner on a Tuesday evening and it was packed. We thought the service was excellent, the food terrific and the atmosphere was just like the many diners we have eaten in when we lived on the East Coast. The major difference being, on the East Coast most diners also offer Greek food, but in this diner there is a Mexican influence in some food items. We thought this place was a very enjoyable experience.

Service smooth, service super great, fast efficient! Si glad we made it in ! I wish i had room for pie or ice cream . Very busy yet these women are super organized and take care of everything and everyone swimmingly

I was very pleased with Hubbard Avenue Diner. Both my meal and my friends meal were equally delicious. I ordered a Denver omelette with hash-browns and a biscuit. The omelette was full of meat, cheese, and veggies, and overall was light, fluffy, and delicious. The biscuit was very delicious as well. The most disappointing thing about my meal were the hash browns, which were bland and undercooked. Lastly, let me tell ya about the pies! I ordered the pecan pie and it was one of the best pecan pies that I've ever had. My buddy got the coconut silk and the bite I had of his pie was equally delicious. If you're in Middleton and looking for a winner, then I highly recommend checking out Hubbard Avenue Diner.